3.23.2011

idol chatter...


Motown week. It's been interesting. Casey was a great way to start the show. Pia, Haley and Jacob were also great tonight. Scotty sang his countrified version of "For Once In My Life" and it made me cringe. A lot. I am not sure why this kid appeals to so many people. He's got some weird mannerisms with the microphone and he looks like he's sniffing dog farts when he sings. I didn't care for Lauren. And Stefano's song choice was... well, it was Lionel Richie, the only person who makes Lionel Richie sound good is Lionel Richie. Paul needs a comb, or is the bedhead thing really a go? Naima, Naima, Naima...must you wear costumes???? They distract from the performance. And then there's James. Really?

I hope the results show is interesting. Ryan had a lot of filler bits, it seems. Hope he didn't use up all his fun bits.

2 comments:

The Gal Herself said...

I liked Casey better last week and I hated Stefano this time around. And then it hit me -- I'm responding as much to the song as the performer. "I Heard It Thru The Grapevine" has been done better, whereas last week's "Teen Spirit" is nowhere near as overdone, and I hate Lionel Ritchie. So I kinda get how hard it is to be a judge.

jon said...

I agree with you about almost everything. I like Scotty.
Singing Motown didn't do him any good.

Yo!.....Yo...dog farts?
Stefano and James can leave any time.

I like Gia Nagila...err..Mia Davila...umm...The cute Asian 16 year old.
Haley I like.
Casey is good.
Or as Steven Tyler would say, "You sang like a farting whale who is landlocked."....Ummm...Huh?